自己动手搭个人智能体:掌控数据、模型与输出
Or just build your own. That's how you make personal agents fully yours. You can sit and wait fo...
两位开发者聊为什么不建议把个人数据全押在 grok bot 这类厂商智能体上,还给了从零搭建和基于 Pi Durable 改造两条具体路径。
Elvis Saravia(@omarsar0)发帖主张与其等待 muse、grok bot 等厂商产品修复问题,不如自己构建个人智能体。他的观点是把 traces、memory 和全部输出都握在自己手里,而 AI 编程工具让搭建和维护门槛大幅降低。引用推文则补充了厂商方案的三个风险:敏感数据托管在供应商手中、被单一模型能力绑死、功能方向受制于产品决策。两条路径包括从零写一个最小版本,或基于开源项目 Pi Durable 改造。
Or just build your own. That's how you make personal agents fully yours. You can sit and wait fo...
Or just build your own. That's how you make personal agents fully yours. You can sit and wait for the next bug fix or for one of these providers to address your safety concerns, or you can start co-evolving a personal agent as needs arise. I have chosen the latter. A personal agent is something you should fully own, from the traces to memory to all outputs. So much resistance to building your own harness and agents. I understand the fear of maintaining yet another thing. But AI makes it easy to build and maintain this stuff. It's not that hard to build agents today, folks. You seriously should consider building your own solution. This is a great time to start. Start from scratch, keep it minimal, and evolve it as you go. Or you can start with an open-source solution like Pi Durable and build from there (btw, Pi Durable is crazy good for this stuff). Kun Chen @kunchenguid there’s something quite awkward about all the personal agents in the current hype cycle muse, grok bot, instinct, dots, and whatever google, anthropic will come up with none of them is “mine” i’d be trusting a vendor for some of the most sensitive data about me and bet on them handling it with extreme responsibility. what if they have a data leakage incident? what if they hired a wrong employee? what if they simply break bad? i’d also be betting on their model. right now i’ve set up a lot of my stuff in grok bot, but what if their model falls behind? what if another model becomes 10x better on pure intelligence? then i’ll either miss out on a better assistant, or have to bite the bullet and do a full migration i’d also have to bet on their product. they may not build the features i want. they may not allow me to customize enough. and one day my assistant may show me ads that feels like way too much betting than what i’d be comfortable with, if i truly want literally everything in my life to go through and be taken care of by an assistant with all that considered, i’m more bullish on open source personal agents that run on people’s own computers. but i think these open source projects have to break out of the assumption that their users are developers and they can just throw a repo at them and ask them to launch a terminal a well polished, fool proof, community maintained, vendor agnostic, free personal agent that everyone can run by themselves without locking into a SaaS - that’s what i think many people will need 🔗 View Quoted Tweet 💬 4 🔄 0 ❤️ 9 👀 1868 📊 4 ⚡