Gary Marcus怼了个流行类比：别把LLM当缸中脑，人的智力靠前额叶，不是靠身体。看看他咋说的。
Gary Marcus在X平台驳斥了一个热门类比，该类比将LLM比作“缸中之脑”。有人以ARC-AGI 3为例提问，若大脑不接身体是否还能完成该测试，并认为加装工具等同于拥有身体。Marcus认为此类比不成立，因为人类智力依赖的是前额叶皮层这一关键脑区。他强调harness应当是大脑自身的组成部分，而非外部附加的传感器或肢体。
This analogy doesn’t make sense; the intellectual harness for humans is (very roughly) the prefronta...
This analogy doesn’t make sense; the intellectual harness for humans is (very roughly) the prefrontal cortex which is a critical part of the brain. simp 4 satoshi @iamgingertrash This makes no sense Would a human mind be able to complete ARC-AGI 3 if the brain was not attached to a body (harness) ? A harness is simply a models motor capabilities, and equivalent of their limbs, sensors, etc A brain in a vat = raw LLM A brain in a body = LLM + harness 🔗 View Quoted Tweet 💬 1 🔄 0 ❤️ 4 👀 1588 📊 1 ⚡