Industry

François Chollet 回顾 2024 年预测:AI 能力暴涨,买入 NVDA 却反亏 5%

Why we picked it

Chollet 拿两年半前的未来数据做思想实验:AI 变强、Nvidia 营收利润全兑现,买 NVDA 还是亏 5%。讨论为什么基本面全对股价照样跌,做投资判断的人很该看看。

François Chollet 回顾 2024 年 6 月 14 日的行业状态:当时模型在 ARC 1 上只有约 5% 的得分,连可靠地做两位数加法都困难,推理模型和编码智能体尚未出现。他假设当时有人穿越回来告知未来:ARC 1、ARC 2(难 10 倍)乃至 ARC 3(难 100 倍)都会被饱和,AI 能一次性完美生成复杂代码库,OpenAI 估值涨 15 倍、Anthropic 涨 85 倍。与此同时,Nvidia 仍占约 80% 的 AI 算力市场,营收和利润增长 4.5 倍,营业利润率从 65% 提高到 67%,年增速仍有 75%。

Body

核心反差在于:即便拿到这些完美的基本面信息,2024 年 6 月买入 NVDA 的人到 2.5 年后仍会亏损 5%,算上通胀亏得更多。Chollet 借此说明 AI 能力的飞速进步与芯片龙头股价回报之间并没有直接对应关系——市场早已提前定价了这些增长预期。这条内容提醒投资者:能力基准的突破和估值饱和是两回事,即使对行业方向的判断完全正确,投资回报仍可能为负。

Original · François Chollet

Flashback to June 14, 2024.

At the time, frontier AI models have zero fluid intelligence. They score around 5% on ARC 1. They can't reliably add two numbers. They make laughable logic errors every other prompt. Reasoning models don't exist. Coding agents don't exist. Claude Code doesn't exist. "Code gen" is a complete joke. Scaling up next-token prediction based on web text data is hitting a wall.

What if a time traveler told you that, by November 2026...

• AI models would have human-like fluid intelligence, thanks to a new paradigm: test-time induction (modern reasoning models). • Not only would ARC 1 be saturated, but unreleased benchmarks 10x harder (ARC 2) and 100x harder (ARC 3) would be saturated too. • Nearly all code would be written by AI, and models could one-shot complex codebases flawlessly. • AI models would be solving multiple Millennium Prize problems. • OpenAI's valuation would be 15x higher, and Anthropic's would be 85x higher.

And on top of all that...

• Nvidia would still hold ~80% of the AI compute market. • Nvidia would have grown its revenue and earnings 4.5x. • Nvidia would still be growing 75% a year. • Nvidia would have even higher operating margins (67% vs. 65% back then).

Based on that information, straight from the future, would you have bought NVDA?

If you answered yes -- congrats. Today, 2.5 years later, you'd be down 5% on your investment (even more after inflation).

Industry Coordinates & Source Verification

This report is categorized under AITOP's "Industry" desk, focusing on US frontier AI labs and Silicon Valley technology leaders. Within our cross-regional analytical framework, it directly maps to AI developer toolchains, coding agents, and engineering workflows. Key entities and technical topics under continuous tracking include Nvidia, NVDA, ARC, AI investment.

Source attribution: curated from François Chollet (@fchollet).