IndustryMulti-source

黎曼猜想证明之争:数学家称纯人工证明,Anthropic 研究员称 Claude 完成

Why we picked it

数学圈这两天真实上演了两个黎曼猜想证明的 PK:斯坦福数学家花 12 年写了 940 页纯人工证明,另一边 Anthropic 研究员说用 Claude 也证出来了。两个都还没验证,人类版发布 8 小时就被人用 AI 找出问题。做研究或关注 AI 能力边界的人都值得看看这场混战。

美国数学会(AMS)主席转发了一份宣称解决黎曼猜想的证明,并强调其全部由人类完成、没有使用 AI。这份 940 页的证明出自斯坦福数学家 Alessandro Masullo 之手,据称耗时近 12 年,且部分章节尚未写完。

Body

就在几小时前,一名 Anthropic 研究员声称借助 Claude 证明了同一个有 167 年历史的数学难题。而在人类证明发布仅 8 小时后,就有网友借助 AI 模型在该证明中找出了问题。目前两份证明都没有经过正式验证。

这轮争论折射出数学界对 LLM 参与严肃数学研究的分歧:从 AlphaProof、AlphaGeometry 到 Claude,AI 辅助证明的边界正在被反复试探,而同行评议速度与 AI 检错速度之间的落差也暴露出来。Gary Marcus 转发此事,意在呈现与 AI 宣传叙事相反的一面。

Original · Gary Marcus

the narrative X doesn’t want you to hear Tornado guy @fanofaliens holy shit, the riemann hypothesis drama just got even crazier 😭 the president of the american mathematical society just posted a second proof of the riemann hypothesis and said it was “all human, with no AI.” this comes just hours after an anthropic researcher claimed he had proved the same 167-year-old problem with claude. > the human proof is by a stanford mathematician alessandro masullo, who says it took him nearly 12 years. > it’s 940 pages long, with parts still unwritten. > a leading stanford mathematician who specializes in the riemann hypothesis has been reviewing the proof for months. > just 8 hours later, people started reporting problems in the proof, found with the help of AI models. the last line of his acknowledgements goes "we are still here. we are very much alive. we are not going anywhere." neither proof is verified yet humans are so back😭 lfg! 🔗 View Quoted Tweet📊 7 ⚡

Industry Coordinates & Source Verification

This report is categorized under AITOP's "Industry" desk, focusing on US frontier AI labs and Silicon Valley technology leaders. Key entities and technical topics under continuous tracking include Claude, Anthropic, Riemann hypothesis, AI safety.

Source attribution: curated from Gary Marcus (@GaryMarcus). Cross-source corroboration: 11 independent sources have covered this development (including Andrew Curran, @koltregaskes, kimmonismus), confirming industry-wide signal strength.