Conserved Verdicts, Drifting Commitments: Identifying Harmful Overthinking
The decomposition shows declining accuracy under longer budgets is largely a chain-selection effect, not models corrupting answers mid-chain — so aggressive early-exit rules built on final-answer probes may target the wrong quantity. Developers implementing adaptive compute budgets and enterprises tuning inference cost versus accuracy on math-heavy workloads can use the commitment-verdict gap as a diagnostic before shipping stopping rules. The modest oracle gains (+1.8 to +2.5 points) suggest limited headroom in current stopping-rule research.