LeCun 批评一份 1991 年技术报告:无理论无实验却声称涵盖一切方法
LeCun 撕了一份自称'所有技术都是我特例'的 1991 年老报告,吐槽它没理论没实验没代码,看大佬怎么点评学术吹牛。
Yann LeCun 在 X 上评论一份 1991 年的技术报告,称其只是含糊的想法,没有理论、没有像样的实验,也没有代码。
报告只有一张手绘架构图和一个类似 f(x)=0 的公式,却声称只要 properly 实例化 f 和 x,其他所有技术都是其特例。LeCun 还指出该作者此后从未重新审视或推进这个想法。
这条推文获得约 93 个赞和 20566 次浏览。
The 1991 version is an obscure tech report with a vague idea, no theory, no experiment to speak of, and certainly no code, that the author never revisited or pushed. It has one hand-drawn architecture diagram, one formula of the type f(x)=0, and a claim that every other technique is a special case if you instantiate f and x properly.📊 14 ⚡
This report is categorized under AITOP's "Industry" desk, focusing on US frontier AI labs and Silicon Valley technology leaders. Key entities and technical topics under continuous tracking include Yann LeCun, technical reports, academic controversy.
Source attribution: curated from Yann LeCun (@ylecun).