IndustryMulti-source

Thom Wolf 解释为何签署针对 Anthropic 的公开信

Why we picked it

签了名的 Thom Wolf 亲自出面解释,说 Anthropic 权力太大但透明度没跟上,还有人怕丢融资不敢署名。关心 AI 安全治理和行业权力集中问题的人值得看看这份一手表态。

Thom Wolf(前 Microsoft/DeepSpeed 相关研究者)公开说明自己签署 Dan Hendrycks 发起的批评 Anthropic 公开信的原因。他表示自己并不完全认同信中 reckless 这类措辞,签署时也不知道声明名称,但认同其中的核心关切。

Body

他给出的第一个理由是:Anthropic 按当前发展势头有望成为影响力最大的公司,这种量级的权力需要接近甚至超过主权政府的透明度,而他担心 Anthropic 尚未朝这个方向前进。第二个理由来自 Dan Hendrycks 的引述:多个 AI 安全团体私下认同声明内容,却因担心影响与 Anthropic 的关系或未来融资而不敢署名。Wolf 称自己也从企业家、高管和研究者处听到同样的顾虑。

Wolf 将这种不敢署名的现象视为权力集中的早期信号,并认为这本身就是第一个实证案例。他表示愿意被证明是错的,并认为 Anthropic 团队有能力做到这一点。

Original · Thomas Wolf

I'm featured quite visibly on Dan's letter, so it's probably good that I briefly explain why I signed while having friends at Anthropic and a lot of respect for them in general. I don't fully agree with the wording. I wouldn't have used "reckless", and I didn't know the name of the statement when I signed, which isn't my style. But I agree with the underlying sentiment and decided to sign for two reasons. First, Anthropic is currently on track to be the most powerful company on earth (and for good reasons, like the quality of the team and product). This level of impact on the world will require a degree of transparency and openness close to, or maybe even higher than, that of a sovereign government, and I'm worried they are not currently on track to reach it. It's a version of "with great power comes great responsibility", applied to social responsibility toward everyone using and impacted by your products. Second, Dan mentions safety groups who felt unable to sign. I heard the same thing directly from a different crowd: entrepreneurs, executives and researchers who agreed with the concerns but were afraid of consequences for their careers or their access to models. Whether or not that fear is justified, I think it's a first example of the problem above, and a worrying early signal about concentration of power in itself. I'd genuinely like to be proven wrong on both points, and I think Anthropic has the people to do it. Dan Hendrycks @hendrycks Numerous AI safety groups told us privately they agreed with this statement, yet felt unable to sign without risking relationships or future funding. Anthropic has almost, but not entirely, captured the ecosystem meant to hold it accountable. 🔗 View Quoted Tweet📊 4 ⚡

Industry Coordinates & Source Verification

This report is categorized under AITOP's "Industry" desk, focusing on US frontier AI labs and Silicon Valley technology leaders. Within our cross-regional analytical framework, it directly maps to AI regulation, compliance frameworks, and sovereign compute policy and AI developer toolchains, coding agents, and engineering workflows. Key entities and technical topics under continuous tracking include Anthropic, Dan Hendrycks, Thom Wolf, AI safety.

Source attribution: curated from Thomas Wolf (@Thom_Wolf). Cross-source corroboration: 11 independent sources have covered this development (including IT之家, The Information, 宝玉), confirming industry-wide signal strength.