Gary Marcus 评 Riemann 猜想进展:神经符号方法的胜利
Gary Marcus 出来表态了:Riemann 猜想这波进展靠的是符号定理证明,纯 LLM 做不到,跟 Deep Blue 下棋一个性质。想搞清这到底是打他的脸还是印证他 25 年的老观点,这篇把逻辑讲得很清楚,搞 AI 和数学的都该看看。
Gary Marcus 在 X 上就 Alpöge 使用神经符号系统在 Riemann 猜想上取得的潜在进展发表看法,称如果结果成立将极其令人印象深刻,但他强调该结果尚未经过严格审查和确认。
他引导读者重读其 2024 年 7 月的文章《AlphaProof, AlphaGeometry, ChatGPT, and why the future of AI is neurosymbolic》,认为 DeepMind 探索的神经符号模型正是 Alpöge 所用系统的前身。
Marcus 断言纯 LLM 至今仍无法完成同样的数学推导,这次的进展是对他 25 年来神经符号路线主张的印证,而非挑战。他进一步指出,即使结果被确认,也不太能改变生成式 AI 的经济性问题,因为其依赖的复杂符号定理证明技术难以泛化到日常推理,类比 1997 年 Deep Blue 在国际象棋上的胜利:专用符号系统 impressively 强大但缺乏通用性。
他还引用 2020 年的《The Next Decade in AI》一文,坚持神经符号进步本身不足以达到稳健智能的观点。
Riemann thoughts: thread with pointer to other threads Gary Marcus @GaryMarcus Hot take on the possible solution to Riemann: 1. The result is incredibly impressive if it holds up. (But see tweet below, it’s scarcely been diligenced.) 2. Anyone who is intellectually serious and interested in AI and math should (re)read my essay “AlphaProof, AlphaGeometry, ChatGPT, and why the future of AI is neurosymbolic” from July 2024, which lavished praise on DeepMind for exploring neurosymbolic models that are predecessors to the systems that Alpöge used with Riemann, and explained (correctly) why pure LLMs could not the same. (Pure LLMs still can’t.) garymarcus.substack.com/p/alphaproof-a… If you think the progress on Riemann is a challenge to me rather than a confirmation of what I have argued for 25 years, you have the argument backwards. 3. The new result has not yet been confirmed yet, just to be clear. 4. But even it is confirmed, it wouldn’t much change the problematic economics of generative AI, because the particular techniques that it relies on involve elaborate symbolic theorem proving techniques that aren’t generally applicable to everyday reasoning. (It’s probably;y more like Deep Blue winning in chess in 1997: a special-purpose symbolic system that was wildly impressive but lacked general applicability.) 5. For more, my 2020 article in the The Next Decade in AI explained why advances in neurosymbolic AI alone would not be enough to get to robust intelligence, and I think what I said there still holds. 🔗 View Quoted Tweet📊 1 ⚡
This report is categorized under AITOP's "Industry" desk, focusing on US frontier AI labs and Silicon Valley technology leaders. Within our cross-regional analytical framework, it directly maps to AI developer toolchains, coding agents, and engineering workflows. Key entities and technical topics under continuous tracking include Gary Marcus, neurosymbolic AI, AlphaProof, DeepMind.
Source attribution: curated from Gary Marcus (@GaryMarcus). Cross-source corroboration: 2 independent sources have covered this development (including Vaibhav Srivastav), confirming industry-wide signal strength.
- Vaibhav Srivastav11-20 15:38Source