Gary Marcus:所谓的"Claude proof"应归功于数学家 Levent Alpoge
这条推文聊的是最近刷屏的"Claude 证明黎曼猜想"话题,但角度很不一样:真正干活的是数学家 Levent Alpoge,他今年连破多个难题,别的有同款模型的人都没做到。关心 AI 与数学边界、也关心署名公平的人值得看看。
Gary Marcus 在 X 上转发 Abhishek Saha 的观点,批评推特上把黎曼猜想证明称作"Claude proof"、抹去人类角色的说法。
Saha 指出核心人物 Levent Alpoge 不只是 Anthropic 员工,而是一流数学家,今年夏天以来连续攻克 Jacobian 猜想、Hadamard 矩阵、S6 上的复结构等问题,如今是 GRH。Saha 强调,许多同样能访问前沿模型和大量 tokens 的人都没能拿出 RH 证明,功劳若证明成立应属于 Alpoge 本人。
文中还提到数学界相当一部分人反 AI,在社交媒体上对 Alpoge 的对待并不公正。
the fact that much of the twitterverse seems hellbent on leaving the human out of the story tells you all you need to know. Abhishek Saha @ObhishekSaha Also, I wish people would stop calling it the "Claude proof", as I am seeing on this website, and instead credit the person involved: Levent Alpoge. Levent is not just an Anthropic employee, he is a top-level mathematician. Others with similar access to frontier AI models/tokens (and trust me, there are many such people) were not able to come up with a proof of RH. Levent has been on a truly generational run since summer, proving time and again his ability to solve conjectures thought out of reach. Jacobian conjecture, Hadamard matrices, complex structure on S6, etc. And now GRH. I think the mathematical community, a large part of which is anti-AI, has treated him poorly, at least from what I've seen on social media. The honour of proving RH, if the proof holds up, belongs to him. 🔗 View Quoted Tweet📊 2 ⚡
This report is categorized under AITOP's "Industry" desk, focusing on US frontier AI labs and Silicon Valley technology leaders. Key entities and technical topics under continuous tracking include Claude, Anthropic, Riemann hypothesis, Levent Alpoge.
Source attribution: curated from Gary Marcus (@GaryMarcus).