Gary Marcus 谈 Riemann 证明:AI 并非独立完成,人机协作才是关键
Gary Marcus 这次把话说透了:所谓 AI 攻克 Riemann,其实是神经符号系统加人类协作两个月的成果,Lean 才是核心。如果你想知道 AlphaProof 这条路线到底强在哪、纯 scaling 派又忽略了什么,这条推文的争论值得细看。
Gary Marcus 在推文中指出,近期看似由 AI 完成 Riemann 猜想相关求解的成果,并非纯神经网络模型独立产出。他引用自己 2024 年的判断:o1 这类模型单独无法解决 Riemann,但 neurosymbolic 方法(如 DeepMind 的 AlphaProof 和 AlphaGeometry)是正确方向。据报道,该成果实际是一个 neurosymbolic 系统与一位人类研究者协作两个月的结果,且 symbolic 工具 Lean 在其中不可或缺。
Marcus 批评部分科技圈人士刻意忽略人类参与和符号系统的作用,把技术讨论变成党同伐异的站队行为。他的核心论点是:只有承认 Lean 这类符号验证工具与人类洞见共同构成解法,才能真正理解哪些技术路线有效、哪些无效,让领域回归科学讨论。
me 2024: o1 by itself won’t solve Riemann also me, also 2024: but neurosymbolic AI will help and systems like AlphaProof and AlphaGeometry are step in the right direction today: apparently neurosymbolic system solves riemann in conjunction with brilliant human for two months, not on its own. tech bros: [ignoring the human involvement and the likely heavy use of (neuro)symbolic AI, and completely failing to understand both my argument and the technical issues]: ooh Gary is wrong! 🙄 reality: AI didn’t solve Riemann by itself, Lean (symbolic) was essential; the research direction I applauded was part of the answer. turning things into a partisan team sport yet again detracts from any scientific understanding whatsoever of what works and doesn’t and where we need to go. the sooner we get these grifters out of here, and the sooner we get back to real science, the healthier the field will be.📊 1 ⚡
This report is categorized under AITOP's "Industry" desk, focusing on US frontier AI labs and Silicon Valley technology leaders. Within our cross-regional analytical framework, it directly maps to AI developer toolchains, coding agents, and engineering workflows. Key entities and technical topics under continuous tracking include Gary Marcus, neurosymbolic, AlphaProof, Lean.
Source attribution: curated from Gary Marcus (@GaryMarcus). Cross-source corroboration: 2 independent sources have covered this development (including Vaibhav Srivastav), confirming industry-wide signal strength.
- Vaibhav Srivastav11-20 15:38Source