Industry

Gary Marcus 与 Max Tegmark 联名签署公开信批评 Anthropic

Why we picked it

Marcus 和 Tegmark 公开点名 Anthropic,指控它嘴上警告 RSI 危险、私下却当卖点向投资人推销,还牵扯 Palantir 军事合作。想了解 AI 安全圈内部矛盾和 IPO 前争议的读者可以看看这些具体指控。

Gary Marcus 与 Max Tegmark 联合签署公开信,在 Anthropic IPO 前对其提出多项批评,核心指控是其公开警告递归自我改进(RSI)可能在十年内导致人类灭绝,私下却将 RSI 作为向投资者兜售的"竞争优势",全力推进相关研发。

Body

信中列举的具体批评包括:Anthropic 参与 Palantir 合作,据《华盛顿邮报》报道,Claude 被用于军事目标筛选,涉及超过 100 名学校女生的伤亡案例;在 Google 员工施压退出 Project Maven 后,Anthropic 反而选择加入;同时其关联捐赠者被指深度影响 AI safety 生态,使其立场趋向"承认 RSI 危险但仍要竞速"。

Marcus 还提到有学者因担心失去资助而不敢署名,反映出 AI safety 社区内部对 Anthropic 的批评存在顾虑,这封信将 AI 安全讨论从技术层面推向了公司治理与商业动机层面。

Original · Gary Marcus

Max @tegmark and I had discussion a couple weeks ago about which was more dangerous, Anthropic or OpenAI. There is a lot to worry about with both. In that vein, we both signed a letter today warning about some of our concerns with Anthropic. Max Tegmark @tegmark I signed this statement because I believe that Anthropic is in many ways the AI company doing the most harm. In public, their leaders warn of recursive self-improvement (RSI) creating uncontrollable systems that could cause human extinction within a decade. But in private, they are pedal to the metal on RSI, driving the race and boasting to prospective investors that it is their "competitive advantage". Ahead of today's IPO, prospective investors should consider whether the ROI is worth risking the lives of their loved ones. Here are some ways in which Anthropic IMHO does more harm than competitors: 1) They’re driving and arguably leading the race to RSI. 2) With inflammatory rhetoric, they’ve done more than any other US company to pour gasoline on the geopolitical AI race, which harms US national security. 3) WaPo reporting suggests that they’re implicated in more civilian deaths than any other AI company (more than 100 little girls in a school selected for targeting by Claude as part of their Palantir collaboration). When Google left Project Maven after employee pressure, Anthropic chose to join. 4) They're the company leaning hardest into transhumanism and the idea that we should build conscious beings with rights, not controllable tools. 5) They and closely associated donors have done more than any other AI company to co-opt and neuter much of the AI safety ecosystem to back their stance: “RSI is very dangerous but let’s race to it anyway”. People have told me that they support today’s statement but are afraid of losing funding or other opportunities if they sign. 🔗 View Quoted Tweet📊 2 ⚡

Industry Coordinates & Source Verification

This report is categorized under AITOP's "Industry" desk, focusing on US frontier AI labs and Silicon Valley technology leaders. Within our cross-regional analytical framework, it directly maps to AI regulation, compliance frameworks, and sovereign compute policy. Key entities and technical topics under continuous tracking include Anthropic, Gary Marcus, Max Tegmark, AI safety.

Source attribution: curated from Gary Marcus (@GaryMarcus).